The Nature and Attributes of God

Contents:

The Knowability of God

The Nature of Descriptive Language

Shared and Unshared Attributes

The Independence of God

The Eternity of God

The Unchangeableness of God

The Sovereignty of God

The Trinity and Unity of God

Discussion Questions

Gender Issues

The Mental Attributes

Spirituality and Invisibility

Love, Jealousy and Wrath

Mercy, Grace and Patience

(open)


The Knowability of God:

Can we really know God?  If so, to what extent?  What is the difference between knowing about God and knowing God?

For us to know him, God must reveal himself to us:

·       Rom 1:19       Matt 11:27      I Cor 1:21      I Cor 2:14      II Cor 4:3-4       Jn 1:18

·       Rom 1:18, 21, 25

 

We can never fully understand God; nor fully understand any single thing about Him

·       Ps 145:3     Ps 147:5     Ps 139:6, cf v.17     I Cor 2:10-12      Rom 11:33     Isa 55:9     Job 26:14

·       We can therefore expect to continually learn more and more about God throughout eternity :   Ps 139: 17-18     Col 1:10

·       I Cor 13:12:  the phrase “know fully” is actually an attempt to translate a Greek word which suggests deeper or more accurate knowledge, not complete knowledge.

 

Yet, we can know God truly

·       Jer 9:23-24      Jn 17:3     Heb 8:11     I Jn 5:20     I Jn 2:13

·       I Jn 4:8     I Jn 1:5     John 4:24     Rom 3:26

 

 

The Nature of Descriptive Language:

Words are always approximations, and “gather” reality into manageable bits.

Different languages often do this gathering in slightly different ways.  Some meaning is always lost, or at least slightly changed, in translation.

Visual example:  a tie-dyed sheet.


 

The Shared and Unshared Attributes of God:

Unshared attributes = “Incommunicable” attributes:  Those characteristics of God that are unique to him, and are not also characteristics of His creatures.

These include:

Self-existence;     “Solitariness”;      Independence;     Unity;     Trinity;     Sovereignty;        Unchangeableness;     Infinity;    Omnipresence;        Omnipotence;    Omniscience;    

 

 

Shared attributes = “Communicable” attributes:  The attributes that we share by being made in God’s image.

These include:

Spirituality;     Knowledge;  Wisdom;      Truthfulness;     Holiness;     Love;     Mercy;     Wrath;     Will;     Freedom;     Beauty;

 

We must understand, again, that insofar as we are created in God’s image, the separation between His incommunicable and communicable attributes is not razor-sharp or absolute:  there is a “flavor” of all of them in us.

God is “eternal”…not in time….but we are immortal, extending infinitely through time in one direction.

God has three persons in his nature, but we have one person in ours.  We are both personal.

We have knowledge, but God has all knowledge.

Except for self-existence, no incommunicable attribute is completely unshared by us, and no communicable attribute is shared fully by us.

 

 

Some Descriptions of God:

Taken from Creation: 

Isa 31:4     Deut 32:11     Isa 53:7     Matt 23:37     Ps 84:11     Rev 22:16     Ps 27:1     Rev 21:23     Heb 12:29     Ps 36:9     Deut 32:4     Ps 119:114     Prov 18:10     Ps 39:11     Ps 91:1     Ps 84:11     Rev 21:22

From human experience:

Isa 61:10     Isa 54:5     Deut 32:6     Isa 33:22     Ex 15:3     Heb 11:10     Ps 23:1     Ex 15:26    

Gen 18:21     Gen 8:1     Ex 2:24     Gen 1:10     Ex 2:24     Gen 8:21     Ps 11:5     Ps 9:7     Lev 26:12     Isa 25:8     Ps 78:40

Ex 33:20,23     Isa 63:9     Ps 11:4     Ps 55:1    Isa 59:1   Deut 33:10     Deut 8:3     Isa 30:27

 

Questions brought up in class, for future discussion: 

·       How do we know what things are not true of God?  Example used:  How do we know that God does not have a wife?

·       What do we do about the issue of gender-words used to describe God?

Anthropomorphism in the description of God:

·       Many of the verses above describe God by attributing human features to Him.  This is called anthropomorphism.

·       It is important that we not take anthropomorphisms literally;  God the Father does not really have hands and feet, nor does the omniscient and eternal and unchangeable God really change his mind.  These expressions are for our benefit in gaining some understanding of the incomprehensible.

·       On the other hand, it is important that we not “dismiss” the anthropomorphism as “just an anthropomorphism.”  It is important to recognize that, in the first place, God made man (anthro) in His image, so it is deeply appropriate, and not just a coincidence, that God’s attributes and actions can be described anthropomorphically.  We have literal mouths with which we communicate with each other because God is a communicator; our mouths are not incidental or accidental, but part of the way in which we are made in God’s image.  Our mouths, arms, hands, etc. all reflect attributes of God, in whose image we were made.  God does not have to “make do” with what we have to explain his own nature; he made us the way we are precisely to reflect his nature.


  

Incommunicable Attributes:

 

The Independence of God

God does not need us or the rest of creation for anything,

yet we and the rest of creation can glorify Him and bring him Joy.

 

 

The Eternity of God

God has no beginning, end, or succession of moments in his own being, and he sees all time equally vividly;

 

Yet God sees events in time and acts in time.

 

The Unchangeableness of God

God is unchanging in His being, perfections, purposes, and promises;

 

Yet God does act and feel emotions, and he acts and feels differently in response to different situations.

 

 

The Sovereignty of God

 

Omnipotence means that God is able to do all his holy will.  God’s will is that attribute whereby he approves and determines to bring about every action and activity of himself and all creation.  God’s freedom is that attribute whereby he does whatever he pleases.

 

Sorting out Omnipotence:

These questions illustrate that there are logical limitations on the concept of omnipotence.  God, like any real being, cannot be other than he is, and cannot act in any way that is truly inconsistent with his own nature.  This is only to say that he is real, and not make-believe.  Any real entity has certain characteristics which are true, and allow one to describe it in definite ways. 

These questions also point out that me must observe the logic of language when we speak about God’s omnipotence.  “Square” is defined as being different from “circle”.  Without making the words useless, there is no sense in which God can make a square circle. 

 

God’s will in general:

 

Some useful terminology:

 

Is God’s sovereignty limited by the wills of his creatures?

  1. This is probably a misleading way to frame this question, since, as we saw above, some “limits” are simply the “edges” of real entities and do not in any way represent a constraint.  It is not that God wants to lie but can’t;  he does not ever wish to lie, so never does.  Falsehood is therefore a “limit”, but not a “constraint”.   A more practical question might be:

Are God’s plans (his secret will) ever frustrated by the wills of his creatures?

  1. Acts 15:18    Num 23:19

Regarding our salvation and election:

  1. Thought exercise:  Ask the question, why was I saved?  To each answer, ask the question again, “Why?”  Where does it end?

 


 

The Unity and Trinity of God

The Trinity in three statements:

·       There is one God

·       God is three persons

·       Each person is fully God

 

St. Augustine’s formulation:  seven statements

1.     The Father is God

2.     The Son is God

3.     The Holy Spirit is God

4.     The Father is not the Son

5.     The Son is not the Holy Spirit

6.     The Holy Spirit is not the Father

7.     There is only one God.

 

Why should we care about the Trinity?   What difference does it make?  Doesn’t this just divide the Church?

·       First, and most fundamentally, all truth matters.  Especially today, in this age of personal relativism, we must be seen as caring not about what makes us feel comfortable or works for us”, but about what is objectively true and real.  If the doctrine of the Trinity best describes the reality of God’s existence, we need to know it.

·       Second, the atonement is at stake if Jesus is not fully God.  Could a mere creature justly bear the full wrath of God for the sin of other creatures?  If not, then justification by faith is also jeopardized:  how can we rely completely on the death of some other creature for our salvation?  There must be something more we have to do.  We see this conclusion in the Jehovah’sWitnesses, who must work for their salvation.

·       Thirdly, we need to know how to relate to these persons.  Should we worship Jesus if he is not God?   Should we pray to Him?  Is that not frank idolatry?

·       Fourthly, and more philosophically, the Unchangeableness of God’s nature is at stake, if he only began to have interpersonal relationships with the creation of us or other created persons.  There would have to be a state before creation in which He was truly alone.  If He is a trinity of persons, he has eternally been interpersonal.

·       Finally, the concept of true unity in diversity is found to be fundamentally true, in the very nature of God, in the Trinity.

 

The term “Trinity” is never used in the Bible, but the concept is progressively revealed throughout the Bible.

First, God’s Unity is explicitly and firmly taught, in the Old Testament:

Yet even in the Old Testament, there are hints of plurality in this one God:

In the New Testament, the teaching is moved forward and developed; we come to know, by name, the Son and the Holy Spirit.

Incorrect teaching about the Trinity:

Illustrations and analogies:

So how do the persons of Trinity differ?

What are the applications to our own lives?

                       


 

Discussion Questions:

(These questions are taken largely from Grudem’s book, Systematic Theology.)

 

  1. So far we have considered the independence, eternity, unchangeableness, sovereignty and trinity-in-unity of God.  We have called these “incommunicable” or unshared attributes.  Yet we are made in the image of God.  Can you see any trace or faint reflection of these traits in ourselves as God intended us to be?
  2. At what point would it be wrong to even want to be like God, or try to be like God in these areas?   When would it become an unholy desire to “be like God”?
  3. For each of these attributes, how do you think we will be more like God when we are in heaven than we are now?  How will we continue to be unlike God even in Heaven?
  4. Considering the independence of God:  how does this doctrine make you feel emotionally?  Does this doctrine have a positive or negative effect on your spiritual life?  How or why?
  5. In light of God’s unchangeableness:   Is it possible today to have the same close relationship with God that people had in Biblical times?  Will we be able to do a good job of raising children in today’s environment?  How does God relate to our prayers today, compared to the prayers recorded in the Bible?
  6. If you sin against God today, when would it start bringing sorrow to God’s heart?  When would it stop bringing sorrow to His heart?  Why did God have to send his Son to bear the punishment for our sin instead of simply “forgetting” about our sins?  Does God now think of your sins as forgiven or unforgiven?  Right now, today, how does God think or feel about sins you will commit a week or a year from now?
  7. If we sing praises to God today, when will the sound of our voices enter or leave the consciousness of God?  What does this thought imply about the eternal importance or significance of our praise?
  8. Consider our prayers.   “When” does God become aware of our prayers?   When does he begin to prepare their answers?

 

 

Gender and the Self-Revelation of God

 

Two issues: 

  1. Gender words for God
  2. Gender words for humans.

 

Questions:

Thought experiment: a new species of fish is discovered, with two distinguishable forms which interact for reproduction.   Which is the male and which female?

It is pretty clear that we would know what we are looking for in deciding which was which!  Even if there is no internal fertilization, the biologist will look for which sexual cells are motile and move toward and into the other.  The penetrating motile cells are called “male” and the larger, receiving cells are called “female”.  Another element looked for is support of the offspring during early development:  the partner whose body or whose germ cell supports the embryo is the female.  In plants, the same scheme is used;  the male cells are the pollen, which move into the female; the female supports the new life.  The nutritive portion of the seed is provided by the female.

 

Note that we have said nothing about which partner is larger, stronger, prettier, or dominant.  This is not inherently part of being female; females of many species are larger, stronger and dominant, and males of many species are  the “pretty” ones.  However, the reproductive scheme is nearly universal:  the male initiates and approaches, goes to the female, who accepts or rejects the advance.  The male cells penetrate; the female provides the nurturing environment, egg, or organ.  Then, in mammalian species at least, the female provides food for the young and the male provides food and protection for the female.

 

 

 

Proposition: Ancient culture was different, and more patriarchal. The language was appropriate then but not now.

 

If God sovereignly chose the language and culture in which to reveal the Bible, why did he choose to use gender language about himself?

 

What Gender language does God use about himself?

 

What Gender language does God use about us?

 

 

Shared (Communicable) Attributes

 

(4 more lessons): Grudem classifies the Shared Attributes into five categories:

·        Spirituality: inc. Invisibility

·        Mental attributes:  Knowledge, wisdom, truthfulness

·        Moral attributes: Goodness, love, mercy, Purity, Peace, righteousness, jealousy, wrath

·       Purpose Attributes: will, freedom, sovereignty

·       Summary attributes: Perfection, Blessedness, Beauty, Glory.

 

 

The “Mental” Attributes of God

We must always remember, in discussing this subject, that God is One real being, and the separation of these various characteristics is only to allow us to focus on them more clearly.   We should realize that there are other ways to outline and discuss these characteristics.  For example, we are going to discuss God’s Knowledge separately from his Wisdom and his Truthfulness, but these are all obviously interrelated; we separate them only for the purposes of discussion.  There is no “standardized list” of God’s attributes, just as there is no “standard list” of your own attributes, but we might easily discuss your education, or your hobbies (though they may be related), your tastes, or your self-control.  You remain one whole person in which all these attributes exist.

 

We are now going to start discussing those attributes of God that are more clearly shared with us.  I did not include gender in the shared attributes, because it is not that God has gender himself as that he uses our gender characteristics to explain and illustrate his relationship to us.  We are male or female, he is not either, but uses our understanding of maleness and femaleness to explain his relationship to us in the areas of creation and redemption, in which he takes predominantly (but not exclusively) a male role and we all take the female. 

 

The mental attributes include those that have to do primarily with mind, thinking and perception.  We clearly share these attributes, though only finitely.

 

Knowledge (Omniscience):  God fully knows himself and all things actual and possible in one simple and eternal act.

·1 Jn 3:20            1 Cor 2:10-11                       1 Jn 1:5

·Heb 4:13            Mt 10:29-30                     Is 46:9-10,  42:8-9 Mt 6:8

·Ps 139:1-16

·What about this idea of God’s knowing “all things possible”?  Consider 1 Sam 23:11-13,  Mt 11:21-23

·What about God’s “forgetting” our sins?  Is 43:25

·What about Jer 7:31,  19:5,   31:35?   (See 2 Kings 16:3,  17:17,  and Lev 18:21

·When should we try to hide our thoughts and deeds from God?

·When did God learn about what you are going to do today?

 

Wisdom:  God’s wisdom means that God always chooses the best goals and the best means to those goals.

·Job 12:13            Ps 104:24

·1 Cor 1:18-29        Rom 11:33   Eph 3:6-10  with respect to the plan of redemption.

·James 1:5                  Ps. 111:10 Prov 9:10

·Do we really believe that God is working wisely in our own lives?  Is this really the best?

 

Truthfulness:  God’s truthfulness means that he is the true God, and that all his knowledge and words are both true and the final standard of truth.

·Jer 10:10-11              Jn 17:3     What does it mean to be the “true” God?

·Num 23:19                 Heb 6:16-18                       Prov 30:5

·Col 3:9-10                 Eph 4:25     Ex 20:16   Prov 12:22

·Jn 8:44            Rev 21:8

·What does God’s truthfulness imply about the conduct of scientific and other types of investigations?

·What does “all truth is God’s truth” mean?

·Augustine:  “When they (unbelievers) found that we believed, on the authority of Scripture, in things which they assuredly knew to be false, they would laugh at our credulity with regard to its more hidden truths, such as the resurrection of the dead and eternal life.”  “..we (thereby) would render our religion contemptible in their eyes, and shut up its entrance into their minds.”    1633 controversy rode on these two verses:  Ps. 50:1 and Ps 93:1.

 

Spirituality and Invisibility

What is God “made of”?  (First problem with the question…God is not “made”…!)  But what is the nature of his “substance” or “essence”.  We have difficulty even forming the question without using words which suggest a creature’s perspective.  Not surprisingly, we will see again that God is not like anything else we know.

 

God’s spirituality means that God exists as a being that is not made of any matter, has no parts or dimensions, is unable to be perceived by our bodily senses, and is more excellent than any other kind of existence.

God’s invisibility means that God’s total essence, all of his spiritual being, will never be able to be seen by us, yet God still shows himself to us through visible, created things, and we will one day see Him “face to face”.

 

 

Love, Jealousy and Wrath

Other than “life”, “love” may be the most important abstract term in the Bible.  God’s love for his people is the “point” of the Old Testament, and of course climaxes in the incarnation and death of Jesus in the New.  “God is Love” is both fundamentally true and one of the most misunderstood and misused ideas in the religious world today.  In this section we want to explore the ways that love is an attribute of God, and how it relates to the less popular attributes of Jealousy and Wrath.

 

Proposed definition of God’s love:  God’s love means that he eternally gives of himself to others.

 

 

God is….

 

In generating the list which follows, I simply looked up the declarative phrase, “God is…” in an electronic concordance.  I have listed only the first occurrence of each idea in this form

 

The jealousy of God:  How does it relate to Love?

 

The wrath of God.  How does it relate to Love?

 

Mercy, Grace and Patience

Mercy: 

Grace:

Patience: 

 

 

References:

This study has drawn heavily, in structure, choice of scriptures, and discussion questions, from the excellent and comprehensive work:

 

Grudem, Wayne;  Systematic Theology: An Introduction to Biblical Doctrine,  Intervarsity Press and  Zondervan Publishing House, Grand Rapids, MI  1994   ISBN 0-310-28670-0 (1200 pages)

 

There is an abridged version of only 500 pages, and still very comprehensive and readable, called:

 

Grudem, Wayne: Bible Doctrine, Zondervan Publishing House, 1999

 

Both are currently in print.    Also recommended and used in this study:

 

Pink, Arthur W, The Attributes of God

 

Boice, James M., Foundations of the Christian Faith

 

HOME:  Mars Hill